| Achievement | Description |
| Amazing | You have solved Bellegar's maze. |
| Baaah | You have met the legendary weresheep! |
| Brutal Truth | You told Aureus that his soldiers are cowards. |
| Captain Jack | You found a job for the unemployed. They will work for Captain Jack. |
| Caught in the Game | You tried to sneak past the guards… And failed! |
| Disciples of the Watch | You sent the Watch after those annoying imps. |
| Echoes from the Past | You talked Ebenezer into... fighting you. |
| Escape | You safely returned to the surface. |
| Fabulous Disaster | The Fabulous Five packed their bags and left town. |
| Feeble Screams from Forests Unknown | You have safely entered Phantom Forest. |
| Fields of Regret | A certain potion wore off and that had some consequences... |
| Find the White Witch | You have rescued the White Witch. |
| Forged in Fire | And water. And air. And Earth. |
| Forgiven | You advised Desdemona to forgive Samson. |
| Gimme Shelter | You have saved the Homestead at the Shelter Plane at the End of Time. |
| Grand Finale | You have totally, completely, and utterly finished the game! Woooo!!!!1 |
| Grizzled Finale | You have made it into the Source Temple. |
| Headlines | You talked to Icara and learned more about Leandra's plans. |
| I Walked with a Zombie | You defeated Evelyn and found Councillor Jake. |
| Into the Void | You have met the Conduit. |
| Is Anyone Home? | You defeated the four elemental demons, unlocking the prison of... |
| It Could Be Mine | You kept Cecil's staff for yourself. |
| Keelhauled | You killed the ghost of Pontius Pirate. |
| Kingdom Come | You made Archibald king of the trolls. |
| Leave My Girl Alone | You saved Bonnie! |
| Live Undead | You informed Aureus about the source of the undead. |
| Locked In | You made it so that Loic couldn't escape and had to fight you alone. |
| Man on the Silver Mountain | You escorted the whole party safely to Silverglen. |
| Mister Nice Guy | You delivered Blossius' will to Marisa totally unaltered. |
| Model Citizen | You returned the mayor's mighty staff. |
| No More Mister Nice Guy | You delivered the will to Marisa... After changing it in your favour. |
| Peace Sells | You found a way to open the barrier without harming any mushrooms. |
| Push It | You pushed this one button we wanted you to push. Congratulations! |
| Raw Deal | You have made a deal with the demon Balberith. |
| Run Down the Devil | You have destroyed Balberith. |
| Sacrifice | You came face-to-face with Mangoth himself. MANGOTH! |
| Shell Shock | You met a talking shell called Ishashell. |
| Skull Crushing Finale | You have finished the Trial of Ascension. |
| Sleeping Village | You made it into Hunter's Edge. |
| Suspicious Minds | You've found your primary suspect. |
| Take No Prisoners | You rescued the prisoners and helped them escape. |
| Team Roller | You thwarted Billeh Gahr's trap with teamwork. |
| The Declaration of Indifference | You have offered one of your own to the demon Balberith. |
| The Mind Is a Terrible Thing to Test | You passed the test! Well, one of many. |
| The Mirror Inside | You have solved the puzzle that we call the Mirror Dungeon puzzle. |
| The One That Got Away | Esmeralda was freed from prison. |
| The System Has Failed | You sent the Watch on a wild goose chase. |
| The Wizard | You have found Zandalor. |
| The World Needs Guts | You found a job for the unemployed with the Fabulous Five! |
| Time to Kill | You have created a spell that makes Death Knights vulnerable. |
| To Hell with the Devil | You have killed Cassandra to get hold of the soulforge repair ritual. |
| Trick Bag | You've found the legendary teleportation devices of Rivellon! |
| Truth Be Told | Get Brandon to tell you the truth about the mining guild. |
| Undeath Is Just the Beginning | You told Arhu about Thelyron's machinations. |
| Unforgiven | You advised Desdemona not to forgive Samson. |
| Voices from the Past | You talked Ebenezer into... Not going to the Hall of Echoes. |
| Well, Well, Well | You have united the well brothers. |
| Whiskey in the Jar | You brewed a fine whisky for Hershel. |
| Wicked Young Man | You have killed Arhu to get hold of the soulforge repair ritual. |
| Wrecking Ball | You destroyed Snorri's ball outside of the time limit. |
| You and Me | Sam and Maxine are going to be wed! |
| You Keep Me Rockin | You kept the Tenebrium for yourself. |
| Zero the Hero | You lied to Aureus and said that his soldiers are true heroes. |
